Friday, November 20, 2026

Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950)

Laura (1944), directed by Otto Preminger and starring Gene Tierney and Dana Andrews, numbers among the most famous and respected film noirs. Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) reunited Otto Preminger, Gene Tierney, and Dana Andrews, but it would not repeat its success. Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) received generally positive reviews, but fared poorly at the box office.

Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) starred Dana Andrews as Detective Mark Dixon, who has a history of police brutality. When he accidentally kills murder witness Ken Paine (Craig Stevens), he takes extreme measures to cover the death up. Unfortunately, the cover-up of the death creates yet more complications for Dixon, even as he befriends Paine's estranged wife Morgan Taylor (Gene Tierney) and her father, cabbie Jiggs Taylor (Tom Tully).

Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) was based on the1948 novel Night Cry by William L. Stuart. The movie stayed fairly loyal to the novel, although a few changes would be made. Detective Mark Dixon in the movie was originally Mark Delgin in the novel. Kenneth Paine in Where the Sidewalk Ends was originally Kendall Paine in the novel. In the movie, Morgan Taylor is a working class model and Paine's estranged wife. In the novel, she was a socialite and only Paine's girlfriend. Crime boss Tommy Scalise (Gary Merrill) was entirely created for the movie. He does not appear in the novel.

It was in March 1948 that independent producer Frank Rosenberg, Jr. bought the film rights to Night Cry. He hired Karl Kamb, Bernard Gordon, and Julian Zimet to write the screenplay. Howard Duff was set to be the star and United Artists would be the film's distributor. Frank Rosenberg, Jr. would never make a movie based on Night Cry. His agent was Ingo Preminger, whose brother was none other than director Otto Preminger. Ingo Preminger apparently talked to his famous brother about the project, who in turn told 20th Century head Darryl F. Zanuck about it. In the end, 20th Century Fox bought the rights to Night Cry from Frank Rosenberg, Jr. As might be expected, Otto Preminger was assigned to direct.

For Where the Sidewalk Ends, Otto Preminger reunited individuals who had worked on Laura (1944), including the aforementioned Gene Tierney and Dana Andrews. Joseph LaShelle, who was cinematographer on Luara (1944), would be cinematographer on Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950). Louis Loeffler had edited Laura (1944) and would edit Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) as well. 

Famed playwright and screenwriter Ben Hecht was assigned to write the screenplay. In Ben Hecht's original screenplay, Detective Mark Dixon was originally the son of a traffic cop who had been murdered. This provided the reason behind his brutality towards criminals. In fact, this was the version that was originally filmed. Unfortunately, Darryl F. Zanuck was unhappy with the movie as it was and demanded a number of reshoots. In the process, Detective Mark Dixon's background was changed entirely, and hence the reason behind his brutality towards criminals. Ben Hecht would not be credited under his own name when the film was released in the United Kingdom. Ben Hecht was critical of British rule in Palestine and a supporter of Zionist group Irgin. As a result, in October 1948, the United Kingdom’s Cinematograph Exhibitors Association began a boycott of Ben Hecht's films. While Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) was shown in Britain, he was credited as "Rex Connor" there. 

While much of Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) was shot on 20th Century Fox soundstages, there was some shooting on location in New York City. The NYPD's old 16th Precinct house at 345 West 47th Street in Manhattan appears in the film. It was torn down in 1968. Also torn down later was the building that housed Ken Paine's apartment at 58 Pike Street in Manhattan. Washington Heights and Times Square also appear in the film.

Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) was released on July 7, 1950. It received mostly positive reviews. The Variety staff commended Ben Hecht for the screenplay, Dana Andrews for his performance, and Otto Preminger for his direction. Bosley Crowther opened his review of Where the Sidewalk Ends with "Fox, which has turned out quite a few superior cops-and-robbers films within the last couple of years, deposited still another better-than-average one at the Roxy yesterday." Harrison Reports called Where the Sidewalk Ends, "...one of the most taut and absorbing crime melodramas produced in many a moon."

While Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) received good reviews, it did not do well at the box office. It was not only the lowest grossing film 20th Century Fox released in 1950, but its lowest grossing film since 1947. Made on a budget of $1,475,000, it only made around $1 million at the box office.

Despite its failure at the box office, Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) would gain a good deal of respect among film noir fans over the years. The Czar of Noir himself, Eddie Muller, referred to it as "..an unjustly overlooked gem." A review from Time Out in 2012 notes "A weatherbeaten Andrews gives one of his finest performances as Detective Mark Dixon..." 

While Ben Hecht's screenplay and Otto Preminger's direction both stand out, it is certainly Dana Andrew's performance that truly makes Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) so special. He gives a good deal of nuance to Detective Mark Dixon, a police officer who is not a bad cop in that he is corrupt or crooked, but in that he simply takes enforcing the law too far. In fact, he takes it to the point that he becomes a criminal himself.  This makes Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950) a rather bleak film noir, and one that refuses to present morality in purely black-and-white. I have to agree with Eddie Muller that it is an overlooked gem.

No comments: