(This blog post is part of The American Exprience Blogathon hosted by Moon in Gemini)In the United States, small towns with friendly inhabitants and exceedingly low crime rates are often referred to as "Mayberry." Of course, the name "Mayberry" originated as the name of the fictional small town in
The Andy Griffith Show and later
Mayberry R.F.D. In both shows Mayberry is a small town in North Carolina. It was peaceful, with the only real crime being moonshiners living outside of town. It was also filled with friendly, if at times colourful, townspeople. In
The Andy Griffith Show, Andy Griffith played Andy Taylor, the sheriff of Mayberry County (of which the city of Mayberry was the county seat), who usually plays straight man to the many inhabitants of the town.
The Andy Griffith Show (and hence the town of Mayberry) originated with producer Sheldon Leonard. If the name "Sheldon Leonard" sounds familiar, it's because he had a long career as a character actor in movies, appearing in such films as
Another Thin Man (1939) and
It's a Wonderful Life (1946). In the Fifties he became a television producer, producing the classic sitcom
Make Room for Daddy (AKA
The Danny Thomas Show). Sheldon Leonard came up with the idea of a man in a small town who was its newspaper editor, sheriff, and justice of the peace. To test out this idea, he asked writer Arthur Stander to develop an episode of
Make Room for Daddy that would also serve as a backdoor pilot for a potential sitcom.
It was the William Morris Agency that would provide the new show with its star. Andy Griffith had risen to prominence on the basis of the novelty record "What It Was, Was Football" and went onto star in the
United States Steel Hour teleplay "No Time for Sergeants" (and later the Broadway play and movie of the same name) and the movie
Face in the Crowd. Mr. Griffith was interested in starring in a television series. As a result, the William Morris Agency contacted Sheldon Leonard about Andy Griffith's interest in starring in a TV show.
The casting of Andy Griffith would have an impact on the prospective new show. It was Mr. Griffith who suggested that the show be set in his home state of North Carolina, although initially Sheldon Leonard resisted the idea. Mr. Leonard simply wanted the show set somewhere in the South. It would also take some time before the town would be named "Mayberry." They came up with a variety of names, among them Mt. Pilot (which would later be used for a fictional, slightly larger town near Mayberry). Andy Griffith pointed out that there was a placed called Pilot Mountain near his hometown of Mt. Airy. Eventually someone came up the name "Mayberry," a name very similar to "Mt. Airy." Andy Griffith believes it could have been writer Athur Stander who came up with the name.
It was then that the fictional town of Mayberry, North Carolina first appeared in the
Make Room for Daddy episode "Danny Meets Andy Griffith," which aired on February 15 1960. That having been said, "Danny Meets Andy Griffith" does differ a bit from
The Andy Griffith Show. Andy Griffith as Sheriff Andy Taylor and Ronnie Howard as his son Opie are the only characters from the show to appear in the backdoor pilot. Frances Bavier does appear in the episode, but not as Aunt Bee. On the show Andy Taylor was only Mayberry's sheriff and justice of the peace, but in "Danny Meets Andy Griffith" he was also the town's newspaper editor. While the idea of a drunk who locks himself in jail when he has had a few too many originated with the pilot, that drunk was Will (played by Frank Cady later of
Petticoat Junction and
Green Acres fame) rather than Otis Campbell (played by Hal Smith).
As a backdoor pilot "Danny Meets Andy Griffith" proved successful. General Foods had first access to the new show and they signed on immediately as its sponsor.
The Andy Griffith Show debuted on October 3 1960 on CBS. In the beginning the show centred on Andy Taylor, the sheriff and justice of the peace of Mayberry, North Carolina. Andy was a widower with a young son named Opie, played by Ronnie Howard. Living with Andy and Opie was Andy's aunt, Aunt Bee (Frances Bavier), who served as their housekeeper and cook. As Mayberry County did not have much in the way of a population, Andy only had one deputy, Barney Fife (Don Knotts). Don Knotts and Andy Griffith had been friends since they had both worked on the Broadway production of
No Time for Sergeants and later worked together on the movie version. When Andy Griffith told Don Knotts about his new show, it was Mr. Knotts who suggested to Mr. Griffith that Sheriff Taylor would need a deputy. In creating the character of Deputy Barney Fife, Don Knotts drew upon Mr. Morrison, the nervous and high-strung character he had played in the "Man in the Street" interviews on
The Steve Allen Show, adding a streak of self-importance as well. Barney would prove to be the breakout character on the show, easily becoming its most popular character.
In the beginning Andy Griffith played Andy Taylor as a country bumpkin not unlike the church deacon in "What It Was, Was Football" or Will Stockdale in
No Time for Sergeants. It was during the first season that Andy Griffith and the producers decided the show would be better if Andy acted as a straight man to Mayberry's many colourful characters (particularly Barney Fife). Because of this
The Andy Griffith Show began to focus much more on the citizens of Mayberry, to the point that the show was as much about the town as it was Sheriff Andy Taylor. In fact, creator and producer Sheldon Leonard would later express regret that the show was named
The Andy Griffith Show, thinking
Mayberry would have been a more fitting title.
With the emphasis on the show shifted to the city of Mayberry,
The Andy Griffith Show developed a rather large ensemble of recurring characters. Among them was Mayberry's barber, Floyd. When Floyd first appeared in the first season episode "Stranger in Town," he was played by actor Walter Baldwin. It would be the very next episode, "Andy Goes Hollywood," that actor Howard McNear would take over the role of Floyd. Floyd Lawson was a bit absent minded and never particularly in a hurry, particularly when speaking. Floyd grew in importance as a character as the show progressed, with Floyd's Barber Shop becoming a hangout for many of the men in Mayberry. The aforementioned Otis Campbell (played by Hal Smith) would also become an important character on the show. Otis was the town drunk, although a somewhat responsible one. He would let himself in the jail when he need to sleep off one of his drunken benders. Not only did Otis Campbell become an important character on the show, but he was also one of the earliest citizens of Mayberry to appear on the show. He first appeared in the show's second episode, "Manhunt."
While Floyd Lawson and Otis Campbell would both prove to be important to
The Andy Griffith Show, two of the most successful characters on the series would both bear the last name "Pyle." Gomer Pyle (Jim Nabors) was a gentle, but none too bright gas station attendant at Wally's Filling Station. The character of Gomer Pyle was based on a an actual gas station attendant that writer Everett Greenbaum had encountered. He talked the new character over with fellow writer Jim Fritzell and producer Aaron Ruben, and so Gomer Pyle was created. As to how Jim Nabors was cast in the role, Andy Griffith caught his act at the Horn, a club in Santa Monica, California. Gomer Pyle first appeared in the third season episode "The Bank Job" and quickly became one of the show's most popular characters. He became so popular that Gomer was spun off into his own,
Gomer Pyle U.S.M.C., on which Gomer had joined the Marines.
Gomer's place on the show would be taken by his cousin Goober Pyle (George Lindsay). Ultimately, Goober would appear more than any other character on
The Andy Griffith Show except for the show's lead characters (Andy, Opie, Barney, and Aunt Bee). Gomer Pyle's cousin, Gomer often referred to Goober well before he made his first appearance on the show. Goober would make his first appearance on
The Andy Griffith Show in the episode "Fun Girls," the only episode in which Goober and Gomer appear together (although Goober would later appear in one episode of
Gomer Pyle U.S. M.C. and they would appear together in the reunion movie
Return to Mayberry). Goober was somewhat backwards and not terribly bright, but he was also an excellent mechanic and repaired cars at Wally's Filling Station. Eventually he bought Wally's Filling Station. George Lindsay would continue playing Goober as one of the leads on
Mayberry R.F.D. He guest starred as Goober on the first episode of
The New Andy Griffith Show, on which Andy Griffith played Greenwood, North Carolina mayor pro tem Andy Sawyer (apparently Andy Taylor and Andy Sawyer were related). He also played the character in an unsold pilot,
Goober and the Trucker's Paradise, in 1978, as well as twenty years of
Hee-Haw (apparently Goober left Mayberry for Cornfield County).
Clara Edwards (Hope Summers) was Aunt Bee's best friend and sometime rival. Clara is a bit of a gossip, something which at times causes Andy some trouble. While, she and Bee are friends, they have something of a competitive relationship. She first appeared in the first season episode "Andy and Opie, Housekeepers." It would be some time before the show's creators settled on the name "Clara Edwards." In her first and second appearances, she is called "Bertha Edwards." By her third episode she had become "Clara Johnson." It wasn't until the sixth season episode "The Church Organ" that she would finally be named Clara Edwards.
One character who remains phenomenally popular did not actually appear that often. Ernest T. Bass (Howard Morris) only appeared in five episodes of
The Andy Griffith Show. Ernest T. Bass was an unruly hillbilly who took great pleasure in causing trouble. He is adept at throwing rocks and takes great pride in breaking out windows in buildings in Mayberry. He tends to be overly boastful, often bragging about his feats of strength. His character can be best summed up by a phrase Barney often said of Ernest T. during his appearances, "He's a nut!"
While there were many recurring characters on
The Andy Griffith Show, except for two of them, Andy's girlfriends did not stick around long. During the first season, Andy's girlfriend was pharmacist Ellie Walker (Elinor Donaue). Ellie only stayed for twelve episodes. After Ellie's departure, Andy went through a succession of girlfriends. County nurse Mary Simpson was Andy's girlfriend for two episodes, although she was played by two different actresses (Julie Adams in the first episode and Sue Ane Langdon in the second). As county nurse Peggy MacMillan, Joanna Moore lasted a bit longer on the show appearing in four episodes. Of course, Andy's final girlfriend and the one he would marry would be Helen Crump (Aneta Corsaut). Curiously, Helen was not initially meant to be Andy's girlfriend. She was merely meant to be Opie's schoolteacher in the episode "Andy Discovers America." As it turned out, actors Andy Griffith and Aneta Corsaut clicked, and as a result Helen Crump became Andy's girlfriend. She appeared for the remainder of the show's run.
While Andy would go through a number of girlfriends on
The Andy Griffith Show, for Barney Fife there was only one. Barney did date a few other women in single episodes of the show and he had an ongoing flirtation with the unseen waitress Juanita from The Bluebird Cafe, in the end Thelma Lou (Betty Lynn) was his girl. Thelma Lou was sweet natured, if at times a bit sensitive. And while Barney occasionally sees other women, he is prone to jealousy if another male pays attention to Thelma Lou, even Gomer Pyle and Opie. Sadly, Barney and Thelma Lou would part ways when he moved to Raleigh. In the episode "The Return of Barney Fife" it is revealed that she had married a man named Gerald Whitfield. To say Barney was crushed would be an understatement.
During the course of
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R. F.D. we learn a good deal about the town. It was named for its founder Lord Mayberry, although the episode "The Battle of Mayberry' states that it was nearly named "Taylortown" after one of Andy's ancestors, Colonel Carleton Taylor. Perhaps the most notable event in Mayberry's history was the Battle of Mayberry, a conflict between the settlers of Mayberry and the local Cherokee. While the inhabitants of Mayberry (including the local Cherokee) have built the event up to mythical proportions, in truth it was little more than the citizens of Mayberry and the Cherokee yelling at each other before making peace, hunting together, and getting drunk together. One fact that cannot be pinned down about Mayberry is its population. A sign in the final episode of
The Andy Griffith Show reads "Population: 5,630." In the episode "The Song Festers," choirmaster John Masters gives Mayberry's population as "two-thousand people." In "The Statue," county clerk Howard Sprague gives Mayberry's population as 1,800.
While there had been fictional towns on television before Mayberry (Mayfield on
Leave It to Beaver being an example), Mayberry may have been the first to have been fully realized. Not only could viewers name many of its citizens, but they could also name many of the locations around Mayberry as well, well beyond the Mayberry Courthouse that figured so prominently in
The Andy Griffith Show. The church Andy attended was All Souls Church. Its denomination was never named (as was the custom on network television in the Sixties), although I suspect it was Southern Baptist. There can be little doubt that there were other churches in town (my hometown has a population of 1,600 and five churches), none were ever shown. Mayberry has one bank and it figured prominently in episodes of
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. Strangely enough for a town with such a low crime rate, Mayberry Security was subject to robberies from time to time.
Several places to eat were named on
The Andy Griffith Show. Although it was never actually shown, the Blue Bird Diner was frequently mentioned, particularly when Barney was on the phone with Juanita. Mayberry also had a diner downtown at which Andy and Barney ate, the Mayberry Diner. Morelli's was a more upscale restaurant just outside of Mayberry and appeared on both
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. Snappy Lunch was another eatery in Mayberry, although it was only mentioned once (in the episode "Andy the Matchmaker").
Several stores were mentioned throughout the run of
The Andy Griffith Show. The local grocery store was called Foley's Grocery or Crowley's Market, leading some to conclude Mr. Foley (Stanley Farrar and Frank Ferguson) owned the store, but Art Crowley (Frank Warren) managed it. Clothing stores included Luken's Style Shop and Mort's Clothing Store. Weaver's Department Store was the department store in town. Other stores included Morrison Sisters Flower Shop, Nelson's Hardware Store, Sterling Jewelry Store, and Willick's Shoe Shop. The Grand Theatre was the cinema in town where Andy and Barney took their dates and Goober watched many a monster movie.
Beyond Floyd's Barber Shop, Walker's Drug Store, Wally's Filling Station, and Emmett's Fix-It Shop, there were several other businesses named on
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. These included Fleur De Lis Beauty Salon, Monroe's Funeral Parlor, Simmons Seeds, and F. Wakefield Beauty Salon.
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. were shot at the old RKO Forty Acres Lot, which Desilu Studios had bought in 1957. It had already been used on such classic movies as
King Kong and
Gone with the Wind. With regards to television,
The Adventures of Superman and episodes of
The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet were shot there. While
The Andy Griffith Show was in production, the lot was occasionally used by other shows, including
Batman,
The Green Hornet,
Mission: Impossible, and even
Star Trek (the episodes "Miri" and "City on the Edge of Forever"). Sadly, the Mayberry lot would be torn down in 1978.
One common misconception about Mayberry is that there were no Black people in the town. While none of the lead characters or supporting characters on
The Andy Griffith Show were Black, Blacks did in fact appear on the show. Black extras were seen as early as the first season episode "Ellie Comes to Town" and would also be seen in such episodes as "Andy's English Valet," "Opie and the Carnival," "Barney Comes to Mayberry," and others. That having been said, the only Black character to have lines in an episode of
The Andy Griffith Show was Opie's football coach Flip Conway (Rockne Tarkington) in the episode "Opie's Piano Lesson." In a retrospective on the show, Howard Morris, who directed several episodes of
The Andy Griffith Show in addition to playing Ernest T. Bass, said that many on the show wanted to include Black characters, but CBS was nervous that including Black characters would hurt the show's ratings in the South. Andy Griffith would later express regret that Black characters had not been cast on the show. Fortunately, the network had apparently changed their mind by the time
Mayberry R.F.D. had debuted. Among the recurring characters was a neighbour of lead character Sam Jones (Ken Berry), Ralph Barton (Charles Lampkin). Ralph had a teenager daughter, Dorothy June (Amanda Sykes), and a pre-teen son Martin (Calvin Peeler).
Over time
The Andy Griffith Show would see changes to its cast. The most significant of these was the departure of Don Knotts. Mr. Knotts left the show basically due to a miscommunication between him and Andy Griffith. Mr. Griffith had said that he would not do the show for more than five years. After five years, then, Don Knotts left to pursue a career in film. On the show it was explained that Barney had left Mayberry to take a job as a detective in Raleigh. Don Knotts would continue to appear as Barney in guest appearances on the show, appearing in five more episodes during the show's run. He also guest starred as Barney in the first episode of
Mayberry R.F.D., "Andy and Helen Get Married."
While Don Knotts left
The Andy Griffith Show for movies, Howard McNear left the show in 1967 due to declining health. He died only around two years after leaving the show, on January 3 1969. Floyd Lawson's absence from the show was explained as Floyd having retired. In 1966 Hal Smith ceased appearing as Otis Campbell on the show.
Just as various actors left
The Andy Griffith Show, so too were actors added. Jack Dodson first appeared as county clerk Howard Sprague in the episode "The County Clerk." Howard was overly close to his mother, something of a Milquetoast, and a bit socially awkward. Howard would become one of the central characters on
The Andy Griffith Show in its later seasons, and was one of the leads on
Mayberry R.F.D. Following the departure of Howard McNear, the character of Emmett Clark (Paul Hartman) was added to the show. Emmett Clark was the local handyman who ran Emmett's Fix-it Shop, which became the central hangout for Mayberry's men following the closure of Floyd's Barber Shop. Like Howard, he would be one of the leads of
Mayberry R.F.D.It was before the eighth and final season of
The Andy Griffith Show that Andy Griffith decided to leave the show and return to making movies. This did not make either CBS or the show's sponsor, General Foods, particularly happy, as the show was still very high rated (it came in no. 3 in the Nielsen ratings for the 1966-1967 season). Andy Griffith was then convinced to do an eighth and final season. At the same time the character of farmer Sam Jones (Ken Berry) was introduced. Sam was elected to the city council and would increasingly play a large role in episodes as the season progressed. Andy and Helen also finally became engaged. Essentially, during its eighth season,
The Andy Griffith Show was transitioning to
Mayberry R.F.D.Although often referred to as a spinoff,
Mayberry R.F.D. should perhaps more properly be considered a continuation of
The Andy Griffith Show without Andy Griffith. It was developed by Bob Ross, who had written several episodes of
The Andy Griffith Show. It should come as no surprise, then, that the format of
Mayberry R.F.D. resembled that of
The Andy Griffith Show to a great degree. It centred on farmer and Mayberry city councilman Sam Jones, who, like Andy, was a widower with a young son (Mike played by Buddy Foster). Andy and Helen married in the debut episode of
Mayberry R.F.D. and moved away, after which Aunt Bee became Sam's housekeeper. Goober, Howard, and Emmett remained on the show. They were joined by a few new characters. Millie Swason (Arlene Golonka) was Sam's girlfriend (curiously, Arlene Golonka had played Howard's girlfriend, Millie Hutchins, on two episodes of
The Andy Griffith Show). Harold (Richard Steele) was Mike's best friend. As mentioned earlier, Ralph Barton was Sam's neighbour on the show. Both Clara Edwards and Emmett's wife Martha (Mary Lansing), from
The Andy Griffith Show, continued to appear on
Mayberry R.F.D.
Andy Griffith would guest star on
Mayberry R. F.D. in its first season. Including the premiere episode, "Andy and Helen Get Married," he appeared in the episodes "Help on the Farm," "Youth Takes Over," and "Mike's Losing Streak." He made one last guest appearance on the show in the first episode of the second season, "Andy's Baby." It centred on the christening of Andy and Helen's new baby, Andy Jr.
Mayberry R.F.D. saw one cast change during its run. After the second season Frances Bavier retired from acting. In the third season episode "The New Housekeeper" it is said that Aunt Bee left to take care of her sister. She was replaced as Sam's housekeeper by his cousin Alice Cooper (Alice Ghostley). Alice was a sharp contrast to Aunt Bee. For one thing she was younger (Alice Ghostley was only around 46 when she joined
Mayberry R.F.D., while Frances Bavier was in her sixties when she left). For another thing, the character of Alice had served in the Army for twenty years before becoming Sam's new housekeeper.
Mayberry R.F.D. proved to be popular on its debut, ranking no. 4 for the 1968-1969 season. It maintained that position in its second season, but dropped to no. 15 for its third season (probably due to new competition from
Monday Night Football on ABC and
The ABC Monday Night Movie). Of course, no. 15 in the Nielsen ratings for the year is still impressive and in any previous year it may have been renewed. Unfortunately, the 1970-1971 season was the season of the Rural Purge. For much of the Sixties ABC and NBC had pursued and attracted viewers in the key demographic of people aged 18 to 34 living in cities, who were perceived as more desirable by advertisers. For much of the Sixties, CBS ignored this key demographic in favour of the overall Nielsen ratings of any given show. All of this began to change around 1967, when CBS cancelled
I've Got a Secret,
To Tell the Truth,
What's My Line?, and even
Gunsmoke because their audiences skewed older.
Gunsmoke was swiftly returned to the schedule as it turned out to be the favourite show of Babe Paley, wife of CBS chief executive William S. Paley. The three panel shows received no such reprieve.
It was then in the late Sixties that CBS decided to change their strategy and pursue the key demographic of urban individuals aged 18-34. This was complicated by the fact that the Prime Time Access Rule would go into effect during the 1971-1972 season. The Prime Time Access Rule was a FCC regulation that effectively reduced the amount of network programming during prime time, meaning the networks had to cancel many more shows than before. With an audience that was largely rural and older, CBS then decided to cancel every single rural show on the air, from the country variety show
Hee-Haw to the sitcom
The Beverly Hillbillies.
Mayberry R.F.D. was then cancelled with its third season. Ranking no. 15 for the year, it remains one of the highest rated shows to ever be cancelled.
Of course, this did not mean Mayberry had disappeared forever. It could still be seen in syndicated reruns of
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. The character of Goober could be seen in new episodes of
Hee-Haw, which entered syndication following its cancellation by CBS. If anything,
The Andy Griffith Show would become even more popular in syndication as new generations discovered the show. It was then in 1986 that the television reunion movie
Return to Mayberry aired.
Much of the original cast returned for the movie, including Andy Griffith as Andy Taylor, Don Knotts as Barney, Ron Howard as Opie, Howard Morris as Ernest T. Bass, Jim Nabors as Gomer Pyle, George Lindsay as Goober Pyle, Jack Dodson as Howard Sprague, Aneta Corsault as Helen, and Betty Lynn as Thelma Lou. Howard Sprague was constantly changing his hair colour in an attempt to look young. Otis Campbell was no longer an alcoholic and was now Mayberry's ice cream man. Gomer now co-owns the gas station with Goober, now named G 'n G. It turns out that Thelma Lou got a divorce after one year of marriage. She and Barney rekindle their romance and finally marry. For the most part
Return to Mayberry maintained continuity with
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. except for one glaring error: Andy and Helen's son Andy Jr. from the
Mayberry R.F.D. episode "Andy's Baby" is never mentioned. The Mayberry set at 40 Acres having been torn down several years ago, Los Olivos, California stood in for Mayberry.
Return to Mayberry proved successful in the ratings. The TV reunion movie was so successful that it could have led to more Mayberry projects had Andy Griffith not already been committed to the TV series
Matlock (then in its first season).
Return to Mayberry would then be the last viewers would see of Mayberry, North Carolina.
There can be no doubt that the success of
The Andy Griffith Show and its successor
Mayberry R.F.D. was largely due to how well realized Mayberry was. Earlier sitcoms had featured fictional towns, such as Springfield on
Father Knows Best and Hilldale on
The Donna Reed Show, but on those shows it was individual families that took a central role, not the town. On both
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. it was arguably Mayberry that took centre stage. The town of Mayberry as a whole was as much of a character on the show as Andy, Barney, or Floyd. People from small towns could watch
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. and identify with many of the situations and even characters on the show. I suspect there are many small towns with a Gomer Pyle, a Floyd Lawson, or even a Barney Fife. In making the town central to the show,
The Andy Griffith Show was something of a pioneer. Mayberry is the spiritual ancestor of every fictional small town and community to appear on American television ever since, including Walton's Mountain on
The Waltons; the unnamed town on
Newhart; Evening Shade, Alabama on
Evening Shade; Twin Peaks on the show of the same name; Cicely, Alaska on
Northern Exposure; Stars Hollow on
Gilmore Girls; and Pawnee, Indiana on
Parks and Recreation.
Of course, because
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. centred on Mayberry, the show was very much a character driven comedy. The show's humour did not arise from one-liners or even from contrived situations, but from the characters themselves. On
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D., the characters drove the plot rather than the plot driving the characters. What is more
The Andy Griffith Show differed from the domestic comedies of the Fifties and even its contemporary sitcoms in other ways. The Fifties had seen a rise in domestic comedies, such as
Father Knows Best and
The Donna Reed Show, that could justifiably be described as gentle. The late Fifties and early Sixties saw a shift to broad comedies such as
Dobie Gillis and
The Beverly Hillbillies, comedies that could be so broad that they could be surreal at times.
The Andy Griffith Show struck a middle ground between these two extremes. It could be very broad at times (such as the episode "The Loaded Goat," in which a goat has eaten dynamite), but it was never so broad that it departed from reality. While many of the situations on such comedies as
Gilligan's Island and
The Monkees were very unlikely to happen, most of the situations on
The Andy Griffith Show conceivably could.
If there is one criticism that can be directed at the portrayal of Mayberry on
The Andy Griffith Show and to a lesser degree
Mayberry R.F.D., it is the town's lack of diversity. I grew up in and still live in a small town not unlike Mayberry. We have a relatively large Black population and many of our most prominent citizens are Black. By the same token, I am part Cherokee and one of my close friends in my youth was nearly full Cherokee. Had Mayberry been realistically portrayed, many of the characters would have been Black and some may have even been Cherokee. As it was, while Black extras appeared on
The Andy Griffith Show, only one Black character (Opie's aforementioned football coach) had lines on the show and only one Cherokee character appeared (Tom Strongow in "The Battle of Mayberry," played by Norman Alden, who was white rather than Naive American). Of course, here it must be pointed out that most other sitcoms of the era did not feature characters belonging to ethnic minorities either, not
The Beverly Hillbillies, not
Bewitched, not
Green Acres. Sadly, while African Americans would increasingly be featured in roles in dramas as the Sixties progressed (examples being
I Spy,
Star Trek, and
Mission: Impossible), the broadcast networks were very reticent to include them in situation comedies. It would take the show
Julia, starring Diahann Carroll, in 1968 to break the colour barrier in sitcoms. While I would have preferred
The Andy Griffith Show to have included Black and even Native American characters in its cast, I also realize that it would not have been realistic to expect them to have done so given the attitudes of the networks in the Sixties. Here I must also point out that things have not changed terribly much in American television. Native Americans are still nearly invisible on the small screen, while East Asian Americans and Latinos are often absent even from shows set in cities with large populations of each (for instance, Los Angeles and New York City).
Regardless,
The Andy Griffith Show would have a lasting impact. Even today it can be found as a syndicated rerun on local stations and cable channels around the country. As mentioned earlier, it would have an influence on every sitcom and drama to feature a small town ever since. It has even had an impact on American English. As mentioned earlier, small towns with relatively low crime rates and friendly inhabitants are often referred to as "Mayberry." A self-important, high-strung police officer might find himself nicknamed, "Barney Fife." Rural people who are not terribly bright might be described as "Gomer Pyle." To a degree it can be said that Mayberry's appeal lies in its nearly utopian portrayal of a small town. It has relatively little crime and any problems that arise can be worked out with a bit of time and understanding. I have no doubt that many watch
The Andy Griffith Show and
Mayberry R.F.D. purely for escapism. For many living in small towns, however, they can see something of Mayberry in their own hometown, from the various characters that inhabit the town to the situations that sometimes arise. If Mayberry became a synonym for small towns across the United States, it is perhaps because at the same time it portrays a somewhat idealized vision of those towns that still has some semblance to reality. To wit, Mayberry was the first small town to be fully realized on American television, and it remains the most famous.
