The title "America's Sweetheart" has been applied to a number of actresses over the years. For a brief time in the late Sixties and early Seventies, it could have easily been applied to actress Karen Valentine, who played student teacher Alice Johnson on the comedy-drama TV series Room 222. If you ask many younger male Baby Boomers (who may have seen Room 222 in its first run) or older Gen Xers (who may have seen it in reruns) about their boyhood crushes, chances are good Karen Valentine numbers among them. What separates Miss Valentine from many actresses who have borne the title "America's Sweetheart" is that she was not of Northern European descent.
Karen Valentine was born on May 25, 1947, in Sebastopol, California. Her father was Portuguese in descent. It was her paternal grandfather who Anglicised the Portuguese surname "Valentin" to the English surname "Valentine." Her paternal grandmother's name was "Avellar." Her mother was of Italian descent, her maiden name being "Casassa." Miss Valentine grew up on a chicken farm in Sonoma County, California.
At age 16, Karen Valentine competed in the Miss Teenage America pageant. While she did not win the pageant, she did win the talent portion of the pageant for her comedic lip-sync routine to "Blame it on the Bossa Nova" by Eydie Gormé. A talent scout was backstage and told her that she was going to get a very big surprise. It was then as the ceremony was taking place that host Bud Collyer (best known as the voice of Superman on radio and the original host of Beat the Clock and To Tell the Truth) announced that Ed Sullivan had been watching the show and wanted it announced that Karen Valentine would be on his show in two weeks." Karen Valentine then made her television debut on The Ed Sullivan Show on November 10, 1963, performing her "Blame It On the Bossa Nova" routine. She would appear on The Ed Sullivan Show one more time, this time performing "You Can't Get a Man with a Gun" from Annie Get Your Gun. Her second appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show was a bigger production than her first, complete with dancers and a full orchestra.
Following her appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show, Karen Valentine was the resident Dream Girl on the short-lived daytime beauty pageant television series Dream Girl of '67. She also appeared on The Dating Game, which didn't prove to be a particularly good experience. She later referred to the whole ordeal as "sleazy."
She would have a much better experience on the television movie Gidget Grows Up in 1969, on which she became the fifth actress to play Frances Elizabeth "Gidget" Lawrence. Her father was played by Bob Cummings and the rest of the cast was filled by such big names as Edward Mulhare, Nina Foch, and Paul Lynde. The movie was loosely based on the novel Gidget Goes to New York by Frederick Kohner. In Gidget Grows Up, Gidget leaves college after two years and becomes a guide at the United Nations in New York City. The show was meant to be a pilot for a new Gidget series. Given it was produced by Harry Ackerman, it may have also been meant as a sequel to the 1965 sitcom, Gidget, although in my humble opinion Karen Valentine looks nothing like Sally Field beyond both being petite and brunette.
While Gidget Grows Up did not result in a new series, Karen Valentine would find herself cast as a regular on a TV series in 1969, Room 222. Initially it must have seemed unlikely to Miss Valentine that she would get a part on the show. She met with a casting director who simply noted her height, the colour of her hair and the colour of her eyes, and nothing more. She did not hear anything for several months when she was called back to audition with producer Gene Reynolds for the role of student teacher Alice Johnson. Miss Valentine thought the audition went wrong from the beginning. She had her sunglasses on top of her head, so that when she went to set her purse down, her sunglasses fell on the floor. When she went to pick her sunglasses up, the pages of her script went flying everywhere. The entire situation actually impressed Gene Reynolds, who saw in her attempt to handle it a good deal of comedic timing, as well as the fact that Karen Valentine's bumbling matched that of Alice Johnson.
Room 222 debuted on September 17, 1969 on ABC. While its ratings were middling at best, the show received critical acclaim and developed a loyal following. As to Karen Valentine, she won an Emmy Award for her role as Alice Johnson on Room 222 for Outstanding Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role in Comedy in 1970 and was nominated again for an Emmy in 1971.
It was while Karen Valentine was on Room 222 that she made guest appearances on The Bold One: The New Doctors; Laugh In; Love, American Style; and Owen Marshall, Counsellor at Law. ABC was eager to capitalize on Karen Valentine's popularity, and as a result a pilot for the prospective series The Karen Valentine Show was shot. The pilot featured Miss Valentine as the assistant to Buddy Loudon (Charles Nelson Reilly) of the Buddy Loudon Public Relations Firm. While ABC did not pick up the pilot, Karen Valentine did receive her own show in the form of the short-lived sitcom Karen. On Karen, she played Karen Angelo, an employee of the liberal citizen's lobby Open America in Washington, DC. The show debuted on January 30, 1975 and lasted only 13 episodes.
Karen Valentine would never again be a regular on a TV show, but she was hardly absent from the small screen. Through the years she did several TV movies, some of which are remembered to this day. She starred in the comedy Western The Daughters of Joshua Cable, playing the pickpocket Charity, who along with a prostitute and a thief are hired by a fur trapper (the Joshua Cable of the title, played by Buddy Ebsen) to pose as his daughters in order to keep his land. She played a stewardess in the TV movie Coffee, Tea, or Me?, based on the book of the same name. Among her best known TV movies is The Girl Who Came Gif-Wrapped. Karen Valentine played the girl of the title, a small-town beauty queen who is sent to the publisher of a men's magazine as a gift as a joke. Despite the title, it was a rather sweet-natured romantic comedy rather than anything salacious. In Muggable Mary, Street Cop, she played the police officer of the title. Notably, she appeared in the original movie pilot for The Love Boat.
Of course, Karen Valentine would also continue to make several guest appearances over the years. On the Starsky & Hutch episode "Fatal Charm," she played an obsessive stalker. After having appeared in the pilot, she later guest-starred on two episodes of The Love Boat. She played a nun on an episode of Mike Hammer. In the Murder, She Wrote episode "Murder Through the Looking Glass," she played a Department of Special Security (a fictional spy agency) operative. She also guest starred on such shows as The Twilight Zone (1985), Monsters, The Untouchables (1993), Cybill, and Family Law.
Amazingly enough given her popularity on the small screen, Karen Valentine only appeared in three feature films. She was the female lead in the 1975 film Forever Young, Forever Free, She may be better remembered for two Walt Disney comedies in which she appeared. She played the female lead, school marm Jenny, in the Western comedy Hot Lead and Cold Feet. She also appeared in The North Avenue Irregulars, playing one of the ladies of a church who decide to combat the mob.
While Karen Valentine was Portuguese in descent, for most of her career she played characters who were Northern European in descent (Gidget and Alice Johnson on Room 222 being prime examples) or Italian in descent (Karen Angelo on Karen and several guest appearances). Sadly, this is not unusual, as it is rare to see characters of Lusitanic on television shows or movies unless they are from Portugal or Brazil. Character actor Nestor Pavia, whose parents were from Portugal, spent his career mostly playing Hispanic characters, with only a few roles in which he played characters of Portuguese descent.
Regardless, Karen Valentine still maintains a legion of fans who never quite got over their boyhood crushes on her. For many she will always be remembered as Alice Johnson on Room 222, the perky, clumsy, and absolutely adorable student teacher. Throughout her career, she also played many other roles, from a deranged stalker on Starsky & Hutch to a street cop in the TV movie Muggalbe Mary, Street Cop to a government agent on Murder, She Wrote. While she will always be remembered as Alice, she played a wide array of other roles as well.






